Cagney's Pizza King Cagney's Pizza King
  • Home
  • Menu
  • About
  • Photos
  • Reviews
  • Location
  • Cagney's Pizza King


    33 E Broadway St, Shelbyville, IN 46176, United States


  • Cagney's Pizza King


    +1 317-392-4677


Service options

+ Delivery

+ Takeaway

+ Dine-in

Highlights

+ Fast service

+ Great beer selection

+ Great cocktails

+ Serves local specialty

+ Sport

Popular for

+ Lunch

+ Dinner

+ Solo dining

Accessibility

+ Wheelchair-accessible car park

+ Wheelchair-accessible entrance

+ Wheelchair-accessible seating

+ Wheelchair-accessible toilet

Offerings

+ Alcohol

+ Beer

+ Cocktails

+ Coffee

+ Comfort food

+ Happy-hour drinks

+ Late-night food

+ Private dining room

+ Quick bite

+ Small plates

+ Spirits

+ Wine

Dining options

+ Lunch

+ Dinner

+ Dessert

+ Seating

+ Table service

Amenities

+ Bar on site

+ Toilet

Atmosphere

+ Casual

+ Cosy

+ Quiet

+ Trendy

Crowd

+ Groups

+ Tourists

+ University students

Planning

+ Accepts reservations

Payments

+ Credit cards

+ Debit cards

+ NFC mobile payments

+ Credit cards

Children

+ Good for kids

+ High chairs

+ Kids' menu

Parking

+ Free of charge street parking

+ Free parking lot

+ Parking


Cagney's Pizza King menu

Draft Beer

US$2.00

Bottle Beer

US$2.00

Well Drink

US$2.00

Coke Zero

$

Water

US$0.00

Lemonaid

$

Vanilla Coke

$

Rootbeer

$

Full Menu

Discover Cagney's Pizza King

Cagney's Pizza King in Shelbyville, Indiana, has become a local favorite for those craving delicious, freshly made pizza. Located at 33 E Broadway St, this cozy diner-style restaurant serves up a wide variety of pizzas that keep customers coming back for more. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, Cagney's Pizza King offers an unforgettable dining experience that blends great food, a relaxed atmosphere, and friendly service.

As soon as you step into the restaurant, the inviting smell of pizza dough baking fills the air, setting the stage for a satisfying meal. One of the standout features of Cagney's Pizza King is its commitment to quality ingredients. The dough is made fresh daily, and the toppings are always top-notch. From classic pepperoni and sausage to specialty options like the meat lover’s pizza or vegetarian delight, there's something for every palate. What’s particularly impressive is the variety of crust options available, including thin, thick, and even gluten-free for those with dietary preferences.

The pizza itself is consistently delicious. The crust is crispy on the outside while still soft and chewy on the inside. The sauce strikes a perfect balance between tangy and sweet, complementing the cheese and toppings beautifully. What sets Cagney's Pizza King apart from other pizza joints in the area is their dedication to flavor. It’s clear that the chefs have mastered the art of making a pizza that’s both comforting and exciting at the same time. Their combination of toppings is always generous, with a perfect amount of cheese that melts evenly across each slice.

Apart from pizza, the menu offers a range of other dishes that make Cagney's Pizza King a great choice for families or groups looking for variety. The pasta dishes, including classic spaghetti and meatballs, are just as flavorful as their pizzas. If you're in the mood for something light, the salads are fresh and crisp, making them an ideal starter before diving into your pizza.

The restaurant's staff adds to the experience, providing friendly and efficient service that enhances the overall atmosphere. The interior of Cagney's Pizza King is charming and simple, with a classic diner vibe that makes you feel right at home. Whether you're dining in with friends or picking up an order to enjoy at home, the welcoming staff ensures that your experience is always a positive one.

What’s great about Cagney's Pizza King is that it doesn’t just cater to pizza lovers. The restaurant regularly receives rave reviews for its affordability and the large portion sizes. Many customers note that they get great value for their money, making it a perfect spot for families on a budget. Whether you’re grabbing a quick bite or settling in for a leisurely dinner, you'll feel satisfied without breaking the bank.

Over the years, Cagney's Pizza King has earned a reputation not just for its food, but for being a community hub. It’s the place where families gather for a quick meal after a busy day, where friends meet up for a casual bite, and where locals go to celebrate special occasions. The cozy, welcoming atmosphere contributes to a sense of familiarity, making every visit feel like a special occasion.

One of the key reasons why Cagney's Pizza King continues to thrive in Shelbyville is its consistent quality and attention to detail. From the ingredients to the customer service, everything is carefully curated to ensure that every customer leaves satisfied. It's not just a place to grab a meal-it’s an experience. Whether you’re a long-time resident or a first-time visitor, you’ll find that Cagney's Pizza King is a place worth returning to time and time again.

If you're looking for a spot in Shelbyville where you can enjoy great pizza, hearty pasta dishes, and a welcoming environment, Cagney's Pizza King should be at the top of your list. Its reputation for quality food, excellent service, and affordability has earned it a loyal following that only continues to grow. Make sure to check it out next time you're in the area-you won't be disappointed.


Cagney's Pizza King Photos

Cagney's Pizza King Photo -1
Cagney's Pizza King Photo -2
Cagney's Pizza King Photo -3
Cagney's Pizza King Photo -4
Cagney's Pizza King Photo -5
Cagney's Pizza King Photo -6
Cagney's Pizza King Photo -7
Cagney's Pizza King Photo -8
Cagney's Pizza King Photo -9
Cagney's Pizza King Photo -10

Location & Contact

Get in touch with our support team


  • 33 E Broadway St, Shelbyville, IN 46176, United States
  • +1 317-392-4677




Clock


Hours

Our open schedules

Day
Monday 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Tuesday 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Wednesday 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Thursday 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Friday 11:00 AM - 11:00 PM
Saturday 11:00 AM - 11:00 PM
Sunday 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM



Reviews

  • We stayed nearby for a couple of days and this little place was recommended by the hotel staff. There was no front signage which made it harder to find than it should have been, but glad we did as the pizza and spaghetti meals we had were really lovely and very well priced. Server was lovely too and was exceptional.

    Mr Tronads
  • Don't let them fool ya. The all you can eat spugotti is boss. One plate you're stuffed

    Eric Heflin
  • Found this little place in the heart of Shelbyville. Staff was good food was also good. The staff is very helpful and will give you an honest opinion on food choices. They had outdoor tables and a good bourbon selection.

    joey glynn
  • 1st snow est delivery 65min but amazed in half time and per usual Carl is great delivery driver compared to dashing. I like knowing to hear I’m a valued customer vs getting msg saying waiting for my food is taking too long. Thanks Carl and Cagney’s but one drawback is prices keep going up but quality not or at times lacking on toppings esp nacho cheese on skins. Get promos for free food and doesn’t cover total knowing stickers up $.60 etc hmm daily specials $up, removed pizza specials online?!!

    Lona West

Explore More Taste

  • 390 Reviews

    Bb Jacks Pizza And Sandwich Lounge

    Bb Jacks Pizza And Sandwich Lounge

    Pizza restaurant

    900 Golf Club Rd, Wausau, WI 54403, United States

  • 332 Reviews

    Green Hill Kitchen

    Green Hill Kitchen

    Barbecue restaurant

    48 Front St, Greenport, NY 11944, United States

  • 322 Reviews

    Tia Rosa's Mexican Restaurant

    Tia Rosa's Mexican Restaurant

    Mexican restaurant

    15445 Valley Blvd, City of Industry, CA 91746, United States

  • 259 Reviews

    Koo’S Bento & Bowl

    Koo’S Bento & Bowl

    Asian fusion restaurant

    3206 S Alpine Rd, Rockford, IL 61109, United States

  • 1339 Reviews

    Tsunami Sushi Baton Rouge

    Tsunami Sushi Baton Rouge

    Sushi restaurant

    100 Lafayette St, Baton Rouge, LA 70801, United States

Cagney's Pizza King

Discover Cagney's Pizza King at 33 E Broadway St, Shelbyville! Serving up delicious, handcrafted pizzas in a cozy atmosphere—your new favorite spot for every slice craving.

The information here is community-driven and not from an official source. If you are the site owner, we welcome you to contact us.